Super Mario Bros. Online Forums

Super Mario Bros. Online => Game Discussion => Topic started by: jdaster64 on May 31, 2012, 06:16:22 pm



Title: Collaborative Recipe Thread, 05/28/12 Edition
Post by: jdaster64 on May 31, 2012, 06:16:22 pm
Basically, this is a thread where we all try to find out the recipe list from the past update.  We've done threads like this in the past, and they've all worked pretty well.  Here's the new part of the recipe list as we know it so far:

Yellow Candy = Yellow Cherry + Jammin' Jelly, 12 HP 18 FP
Yellow Cake = Yellow Cherry + Cake Mix, 5 HP 9 FP
Memory Cake = Refreshshroom, cannot be used
Yellow-Blue Meal = Yellow Candy + Blue Candy, 16 HP 22 FP
Red-Yellow Meal = Red Candy + Yellow Candy, 24 HP 14 FP
Blue-Red Meal = Blue Candy + Red Candy, 19 HP 19 FP
Ultra Nuts = Nuts + Sweet Syrup, 14 HP 7 FP over 7s
Rock Candy = Rock + Sweet Syrup, 6 HP 13 FP
Bombastic Egg = Egg + Poison Shroom, 13 HP 6 FP 50 SP
Potato Salad = Weird Potato, 6 HP 2 FP
Fruit Parfait = Exotic Mango + Sweet Syrup, 3 HP 16 FP
Fruit Parfait = Exotic Mango + Cake Mix, 3 HP 16 FP
Super Soda = Beanish Lime, 9 FP 35 SP
Super Soda = Beanish Lime + Mushroom Soda, 9 FP 35 SP
Sweeter Syrup = Ultra Nuts + Point Swap, 17 FP

Any help filling in the missing recipes would be appreciated!


Title: Re: Collaborative Recipe Thread, 05/28/12 Edition
Post by: Penguin4478 on May 31, 2012, 09:46:55 pm
I made LOTS of attempts, but to no avail:
Beanish Lime+all 3 Mushroom Kingdom FP restoring items (syrups and jelly)
Poison Shroom + 3 MK FP items
Red + Green pepper
Green Pepper alone
Red Pepper + Point Swap
Beanish Lime + Poison Shroom
There are a few more, but I forgot them

I asked around, and here are some suggestions and some of my own ideas if you want to try them out:
Poison Shroom + Pepper (Suggested by Firebros)
Mango + Poison Shroom
Nuts + Poison Shroom
Pepper + Mango

Another thing I noticed: The memory cake's description says something about the chef's secret cake mix. Perhaps you were right about another type of cake + poison shroom = trial stew, but this is all just a theory that somehow strung together. Perhaps there is another new type of cake mix now though.


Title: Re: Collaborative Recipe Thread, 05/28/12 Edition
Post by: Penguin4478 on June 01, 2012, 05:09:20 pm
*Bump*
Yea, this is seriously difficult... I wish Kimi or Hydra would give us atleast a couple hints.
Firebros and I tried over 50 different combinations of items, including lots of things implementing point swaps, testing to see if there were lime candies, syrup shrooms (like honey or maple shrooms), and a bunch of other stuff. We didn't get a SINGLE recipe...


Title: Re: Collaborative Recipe Thread, 05/28/12 Edition
Post by: jdaster64 on June 01, 2012, 07:30:49 pm
Tenth recipe added!  Check the top post!


Title: Re: Collaborative Recipe Thread, 05/28/12 Edition
Post by: Penguin4478 on June 02, 2012, 09:22:37 am
Something just occurred to me: What if there's an ultra syrup, like an ultra nuts? According to kimi, finding one recipe will open the way for many others, so I think this ultra syrup is the key. Now...how to make it?


Title: Re: Collaborative Recipe Thread, 05/28/12 Edition
Post by: jdaster64 on June 21, 2012, 02:26:30 pm
Some known Mistakes, for the reader's foreknowledge:
Egg+Beanish Lime
Egg+Weird Potato
Egg+Potato Salad
Egg+Yellow Berry
Egg+Rock
Egg+Nuts
Egg+Sweet Syrup
Egg+Exotic Mango
Egg+Honey Syrup
Egg+Mushroom (either type)
Egg+Super Shroom
Egg+Ultra Shroom
Egg+All herbs
Egg+Red Pepper


Title: Re: Collaborative Recipe Thread, 05/28/12 Edition
Post by: Kimimaru on June 21, 2012, 05:49:45 pm
Here's another hint: A few of the new recipes involve recipes made from fruit.


Title: Re: Collaborative Recipe Thread, 05/28/12 Edition
Post by: Penguin4478 on June 21, 2012, 07:56:59 pm
hmm... possibly something else like alternative fruit parfait recipes?


Title: Re: Collaborative Recipe Thread, 05/28/12 Edition
Post by: Penguin4478 on June 24, 2012, 10:55:23 pm
A double-post to bump the topic.

Maybe Firebros and I were on the right track with the lime candy idea? Kimi said one of those trials was on the right track, and now he says to use fruit, so I'm supposing that possibly could be it. Also, an ingredient rhymes with "leg."

Firebros Suggested Soda + Mango = another type of soda, but I doubt it


Title: Re: Collaborative Recipe Thread, 05/28/12 Edition
Post by: jdaster64 on June 25, 2012, 10:51:01 am
Doesn't necessarily have to be the same recipe.  If it is, there can't be too many things to try.

EDIT: And to be precise, he said they involved recipes made from fruit, not just fruit.


Title: Re: Collaborative Recipe Thread, 05/28/12 Edition
Post by: jdaster64 on July 02, 2012, 08:30:49 am
Added three of the five remaining recipes!  Come on, people, let's figure out what those last two are!  One involves an egg of some sorts, and I'd bet the last one is another soda recipe.  Go figure that I tried combining cherries, but never candies.

Also, odd that Blue-Red Meal sells for 30 Beanbean coins when you can make it prior to going to Beanbean Outskirts.  I'll see if I can get Kimi to fix that.


Title: Re: Collaborative Recipe Thread, 05/28/12 Edition
Post by: Penguin4478 on July 02, 2012, 09:49:08 am
Huh? I was sure I did mix the 2 berry types together...

Oh wait, derp, I mixed the lime and the lemon together >.>


Title: Re: Collaborative Recipe Thread, 05/28/12 Edition
Post by: Kimimaru on July 02, 2012, 03:57:03 pm
Also, odd that Blue-Red Meal sells for 30 Beanbean coins when you can make it prior to going to Beanbean Outskirts.  I'll see if I can get Kimi to fix that.

You can? I think you should try it out; you'll be surprised!


Title: Re: Collaborative Recipe Thread, 05/28/12 Edition
Post by: jdaster64 on July 02, 2012, 04:59:05 pm
You mean the new recipes are locked to Bean B.'s alone?  Either way, not sure why they're all 30 BB coins when the Yellow Candy alone sells for 45.


Title: Re: Collaborative Recipe Thread, 05/28/12 Edition
Post by: Penguin4478 on July 02, 2012, 08:35:23 pm
hmm... another idea came over me:
The hint merely stated the thing rhymed with "leg," so it's possible that cooked egg rather than just a normal egg is part of a recipe!


Title: Re: Collaborative Recipe Thread, 05/28/12 Edition
Post by: jdaster64 on July 02, 2012, 10:21:40 pm
I considered that, but I couldn't think of anything that would make any more sense being made with a Cooked Egg than with a regular one.


Title: Re: Collaborative Recipe Thread, 05/28/12 Edition
Post by: Penguin4478 on July 03, 2012, 06:53:31 pm
maybe a breakfast plate/diner plate? I mean, it's unlikely, but using a cooked egg would probably result in a recipe that's just a combination of the 2.


Title: Re: Collaborative Recipe Thread, 05/28/12 Edition
Post by: hydrakiller4000 on July 04, 2012, 12:16:16 am
The ingredient that rhymes with "leg" is one of the two ingredients for the recipe. The other ingredient rhymes with "loom."


Title: Re: Collaborative Recipe Thread, 05/28/12 Edition
Post by: Penguin4478 on July 04, 2012, 01:14:32 am
That "oom" must be a shroom... Egg + ultra shroom/poison shroom?


Title: Re: Collaborative Recipe Thread, 05/28/12 Edition
Post by: jdaster64 on July 04, 2012, 11:22:04 am
Must be poison (let's hope it's not life); I keep forgetting to try that. EDIT: it is.  Effectively, thanks for the reminder, Hydra.

Again, I'd bet money that the last recipe is some type of soda, so we should try recipes for that out later today!


Title: Re: Collaborative Recipe Thread, 05/28/12 Edition
Post by: Penguin4478 on July 04, 2012, 01:44:22 pm
woah, I thought you already tried that too, so I didn't... XD
 Anyways, I'm glad poison was used for something, considering I was questioning its existence


Title: Re: Collaborative Recipe Thread, 05/28/12 Edition
Post by: jdaster64 on July 05, 2012, 09:56:32 pm
Failed third soda-related recipes, if that is indeed what it is:
lime+mango
lime+yellow cherry
lime+super shroom
lime+honey
lime+maple
lime+sweet syrup
lime+tasty tonic
mushroom soda+super shroom
super soda+mango
super soda+yellow cherry
super soda+honey
super soda+maple
super soda+jelly
super soda+sweet syrup
super soda+mushroom
super soda+mushroom (mk)
super soda+super shroom
super soda+ultra shroom
super soda+mushroom soda
super soda+point swap


Title: Re: Collaborative Recipe Thread, 05/28/12 Edition
Post by: Kimimaru on July 06, 2012, 12:54:02 am
I remember telling you guys that there was a recipe involving Point Swap; did you experiment more with that?


Title: Re: Collaborative Recipe Thread, 05/28/12 Edition
Post by: Penguin4478 on July 06, 2012, 09:04:49 am
D'OH! Can't believe I totally neglected that.

If there is a recipe with point swap, wouldn't that mean there should be 2 recipes with it, considering logic is into play?


Title: Re: Collaborative Recipe Thread, 05/28/12 Edition
Post by: jdaster64 on July 06, 2012, 10:38:27 am
considering what's been tried, mushroom soda + point swap's not unlikely.  There's probably something better though; we just need to think of something that's not obviously two-way reversible (mushrooms, syrups, peppers).  Ultra Nut's probably not a bad one to try either.


Title: Re: Collaborative Recipe Thread, 05/28/12 Edition
Post by: Penguin4478 on July 06, 2012, 11:28:31 am
Hmm... I was seriously doubting this, but now it does make sense:
Life Shroom + point swap = poison shroom
Considering there really can't be a way to make infinite life shrooms, this is a good way to make a 1-way recipe for point swap, although sacrificing Life Shrooms will be tricky...


Title: Re: Collaborative Recipe Thread, 05/28/12 Edition
Post by: Kimimaru on July 06, 2012, 02:38:47 pm
Life Shrooms aren't used in any recipes.

Fun Fact: The item obtained from the recipe made with Point Swap was originally going to be unused.


Title: Re: Collaborative Recipe Thread, 05/28/12 Edition
Post by: jdaster64 on July 06, 2012, 04:21:49 pm
Got it, it was one of my suspicions.


Title: Re: Collaborative Recipe Thread, 05/28/12 Edition
Post by: Penguin4478 on July 06, 2012, 08:12:07 pm
ultra nuts + point swap = syrup? That barely makes sense ._.

Atleast SMBO is now 100% complete again!